Sony Cybershot P150 or Canon S60?

 

New member
Username: Mikearnott

Post Number: 1
Registered: Dec-04
I am looking at buying 1 of 2 camera within the next few days.
They are:

1) Sony Cybershot P150 - $600 CDN, 7.2 MP, No RAW, good video
30fps, 3X zoom, limited manual
controls

2) Canan Powershot S60 - $600 CDN, 5.0 MP, RAW, poor video 10
fps, 3.6X zoom, intervalometer



Can you please tell me what you think I should buy. One or the
other. No grey area.

My synopsis:

I am an amatuer photographer and have done some excellent
photos with lower megapixel cameras. I
now have the resources to purchase a better camera with high
megapixels and more features. I wish to
be able to blow pictures up to 16x20 and place them on the wall
(so near photo quality, but viewed
from a few feet back). On the one hand the P150 has no RAW
format but much higher megapixels, and
much better video. I plan to use some video but am buying the
camera for pictures, not video but
it's definately a nice feature. The Canon S60, has RAW format
but only has 5.0 MP. It has a little
more zoom but seems to has lots of noise at higher ISO's. As
well the video is limited to 30 seconds
and only 10fps. With that being said, please advise me on your
thoughts. Will both camera produce
extremely nice 16x20's or will the JPEG only format of the Sony
really not have the colors in the
photo that the the Canon would produce. On the other hand would
the 5.0 MP of the Canon start to
pixelate where the 7.0 MP of the Sony would excel. Or again
would the pictures be comparable. I
would like to be able to take nice night shots as well, both
have long shutter speeds (15 seconds I
believe) which will help but I have heard the Canon has more
noise.

The video I am not so concerned with. One has good video while
the other has the intervalometer
which is an interesting feature.



Please try to give me an aswser as to one or the other. If you
have any other suggestion please
also let me know them.



Thank you so much for taking the time. It is much appreciated
and I will let you know which I get.

Mike Arnott

P.S. Considered the Fugi E550 but heard the 6MP setting over compresses and the LCD is hard to see
 

Gold Member
Username: Project6

Post Number: 2176
Registered: Dec-03
The megaapixel war is moot on point and shoot cameras, their sensors are all the same size and still cannot rival the picture quality of adigital SLR even at 4 megapixels.

With that said, Canon having the RAW format is a better feature than what Sony has to offer. Noise at high ISO can be fixed with various programs specially with the RAW format.

Both cameras should produce good quality pictures at 16x20.


The video feature is not even a deal breaker for me.
« Previous Thread Next Thread »



Main Forums

Today's Posts

Forum Help

Follow Us