Why won't by Super VHS VCR play SVHS-ET tapes?

 

Troy Heagy
Unregistered guest
Follow the steps:
(1) Record SVHS-ET onto standard VHS (w/ JVC VCR)
(2) Insert SVHS-ET tape into older Panasonic Super-VHS VCR
(3) Press play & the image is black-n-white with strange floating colors bands

What's the deal?

Is SVHS-ET a different standard than normal SVHS?

troy
 

Silver Member
Username: Samijubal

Post Number: 992
Registered: Jul-04
Yes, if you want S-VHS recordings you have to use an S-VHS tape.
 

Troy Heagy
Unregistered guest
Thanks.

So, what are the specs for SVHS-ET?

troy
 

Silver Member
Username: Samijubal

Post Number: 994
Registered: Jul-04
Here is an explanation of S-VHS.
http://www.autobahn.mb.ca/~glenap/svhs.html
 

Troy Heagy
Unregistered guest
That link says SVHS-ET is the *same* as SVHS.

It seems odd they'd invent a new acronym for the same standard.

troy
 

Silver Member
Username: Samijubal

Post Number: 997
Registered: Jul-04
I see nowhere where it says it's the same. True S-VHS recording isn't possible on a standard VHS tape, VHS and S-VHS tapes are different.
 

Troy Heagy
Unregistered guest
Actually, you CAN record record the S-VHS signal on to a standard VHS:

"Early in the life of the format [~1990], enthusiasts such as myself started to experiment with VHS tape formulations at SVHS quality. We found that we could drill a similar recognition hole into a standard VHS cassette and the SVHS VCR would then see this tape as an SVHS tape."

"S-VHS tapes are simply a higher grade of VHS tape, and nothing more."

https://www.ecoustics.com/electronics/products/articles/124304.html
 

Troy Heagy
Unregistered guest
P.S.

I'm still looking for specs (bandwidth, frequency, et cetera) for S-VHS-ET. Anyone know where I can find it?

troy
 

Gold Member
Username: Samijubal

Post Number: 1002
Registered: Jul-04
S-VHS tapes have a different bandwidth, they are not standard VHS. They need this higher bandwidth to get the 400 lines of resolution that S-VHS has. Fooling the VCR into thinking it's an S-VHS tape will not get you S-VHS recordings.
 

raybest
Unregistered guest
Is it true that SVHS tapes copied to VHS tapes reduces the picture quality to VHS quality? I have been editing all my Hi8 and now Digital 8 camcorder tapes onto SVHS tape using an S-video cable. I have then sent copies from the S-video tapes to VHS tapes to my friends thinking they were getting better picture quality tapes. Sounds like I could have just copied direct from VHS tapes other than having SVHS quality for my own benefit.
Ray
 

Gold Member
Username: Samijubal

Post Number: 1036
Registered: Jul-04
When copying to VHS the resolution will be 240 lines max, pathetic in today's world. That being said, the higher the source resolution the better the recording will look. But compared to the 400 lines of S-VHS, regular VHS is going to be poor quality. Use a DVD recorder if you want good quality.
« Previous Thread Next Thread »



Main Forums

Today's Posts

Forum Help

Follow Us