Opinions please - upgrading system

 

New member
Username: Simon22

South Croydon, Surrey United Kingdom

Post Number: 1
Registered: Aug-05
Hello all,

Curently I have a Yamaha DSP-AX620 surround amp running music from my Ipod (through a dock) to Mission 700s. Which sounds fairly decent for a mongrel system culled from the bits and pieces I could fit in the car to uni.

However, having finished uni I want to upgrade to a solely hifi system. I'm thinking of keeping the ipod (budget restraints) and getting the NAD352 and some Wharfedale diamond 9.1s.

So, if using the ipod as a source, is it pointless to get such expensive kit? Will it be an big improvement from the surround amp anyway? And any thoughts on the amp/speaker match.

Many thanks
 

Gold Member
Username: Project6

Post Number: 3405
Registered: Dec-03
Will the iPod be the only source?
 

Silver Member
Username: Frank_abela

Berkshire UK

Post Number: 775
Registered: Sep-04
I use the iPod on my system occasionally (AAC recordings at 192k) and it's not half bad. It won't be disgraced into a 352 by any means. As to speakers, I'd have a look at B&W DM600s as well.

Regards,
Frank.
 

New member
Username: Simon22

Post Number: 2
Registered: Aug-05
Berny, the ipod will be the only source initially, for the first six months at least I expect.

Thanks Frank.

Simon
 

Silver Member
Username: Cheapskate

Post Number: 226
Registered: Mar-04
if you switch to an NAD amp, $500pr magnepan MMG planars will give you a HUGE bang for your buck. i wouldn't use them with the yamaha though as nearly all sub $1000 recievers hate 4 ohm loads. NAD is the cheapest route to using maggies.

the strengths of planars are:
lighning fast transients
they kick reality butt on vocals
their midrange sounds so flat and coherent
they move ALOT of air in the midrange (scale)
they stay clear at high volumes
they have no box resonances at all
and
you can chose from 3 wood finishes and 3 grille cloth colors when ordering.

hearing $1200 maggies locally, i've totally given up on my 20 year long "only acoustic suspension minimonitors will do" priorities and now want speakers that sound more like the actual sounds they're playing... vocals, piano and metallic percussion etc.

planar shortcomings are:
extremely power hungry
they are ositioning fussy
they don't image as well as smaller speakers (but their higher level of sonic realim more than comensates for image localization)
they are amplifier fussy (4 ohm output)
and
they don't have the bass extension of dynamic speakers (but you've NEVER heard a bass drum sound so tight! LOL)

it's surely no coincidence that something like 90% of stereophile readers report they own maggies.

if you're a bass freak... plan on getting a subwoofer. personally, i'd love to GET RID OF my 12" sub and use a planar as a more refined subwoofer with the rolled off bass that i prefer.

you won't FEEL planar bass, but you will hear it clearly.

as to B&W DM600s, they've only gotten lukewarm reviews from what i've read and i actually like the sound of my $200 pr. NHT super zeros MORE than $1000 B&Ws which have sloppy ported bass and don't image as precisely as my tiny speakers. B&W tweeters have super speed and extension though.

that is one area where B&W surprised me actually. i didn't expect a dome tweeter to sound more extended than a magneplanar ribbon, but it did. still, the $1200 maggies i auditioned walked all over the B&Ws for midrange speed and clarity. their bass was several times faster and more detailed than those B&W boom boxes. LOL

from everything i've read, smaller maggies sound just like bigger ones only with less bass. that should make $500 MMGs a steal then. as smaller speakers, they probably image more precisely than the bigger models, and MMGs actaully have MORE treble extension than their bigger brothers until you hit the $3700 mark.

if you can, go listen to maggies yourself to see if they float your boat.

i liked $1200 maggies on simarly priced gear MORE than $20,000 B&Ws on outrageosly expensive mcintosh gear.

i'm a born again midrange freak! LOL
« Previous Thread Next Thread »



Main Forums

Today's Posts

Forum Help

Follow Us